The Truth About Stevia — A Functional Medicine Perspective

Is Stevia a safe alternative to sweeteners or sugar?

Sweeteners are everywhere in today’s food supply, and one of the most common questions we hear from patients is:

“Is stevia a healthy alternative to sugar?”

At Thrive Functional Health, we do support the use of plant-based sweeteners such as stevia, monk fruit, and small amounts of honey, when used intentionally and in moderation. But understanding why we make that recommendation—and how stevia differs from artificial sweeteners—is key to making informed choices for metabolic and gut health.

Why Sweeteners Matter for Metabolic Health

Excess sugar intake is a well-known contributor to:

• Insulin resistance

• Blood sugar dysregulation

• Inflammation

• Weight gain

In an effort to reduce sugar, many people turn to artificial sweeteners such as aspartame, sucralose, and saccharin. While these products contain little to no calories, research increasingly shows they may negatively impact metabolic health, particularly by altering gut bacteria and interfering with insulin signaling.

Studies suggest artificial sweeteners can:

• Disrupt the gut microbiome

• Increase glucose intolerance

• Contribute to insulin resistance

• Worsen brain fog and cravings

This means that although they don’t raise blood sugar directly, they may still drive the very metabolic issues people are trying to avoid.

What Is Stevia?

Stevia is derived from the leaves of the plant Stevia rebaudiana, native to South America. The sweet compounds—called steviol glycosides—are extracted and purified to create a non-caloric sweetener that is approximately 200–300 times sweeter than sugar.

Highly purified stevia extracts are classified as Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS) and are widely used in food and beverage products.

How Stevia Is Metabolized in the Body

Stevia behaves very differently in the body compared to sugar and artificial sweeteners.

• Steviol glycosides are not absorbed in the small intestine

• They reach the colon intact, where gut bacteria break them down into steviol

• Steviol is absorbed, processed by the liver into steviol glucuronide, and then excreted in the urine

Because of this process:

• Stevia does not raise blood glucose

• It does not significantly stimulate insulin

• It does not provide usable calories

This metabolic pathway is one reason stevia is often well tolerated in individuals working to balance blood sugar.

Stevia vs. Artificial Sweeteners

From a functional medicine perspective, the distinction matters:

• Sugar: Raises blood glucose and insulin, contributing to inflammation and metabolic dysfunction

• Artificial sweeteners: May disrupt gut bacteria and impair glucose regulation despite being calorie-free

• Stevia: Appears metabolically neutral, with research showing no meaningful rise in blood sugar or insulin when used in moderation

Current evidence does not support claims that stevia causes insulin resistance or gut damage in humans when consumed at reasonable amounts.

Facts vs. Myths About Stevia

Myth: Stevia spikes insulin. Fact: Human studies show little to no insulin response compared to sugar

Myth: Stevia damages gut health. Fact: Current research does not show significant harmful changes to gut microbiota with moderate intake

Myth: Stevia is “just as bad as artificial sweeteners.”Fact: Stevia’s metabolism and gut interaction are fundamentally different from synthetic sweeteners

Our Clinical Perspective

Stevia is not a health food, and it is not meant to be consumed without limits. However, when used intentionally and in moderation, stevia can be a helpful tool for:

• Reducing added sugar intake

• Supporting blood sugar balance

• Transitioning away from artificial sweeteners

We also encourage:

• Monk fruit as another plant-based option

• Small amounts of honey or maple syrup, when appropriate

• Gradually reducing overall sweetness to retrain taste preferences

The goal is not perfection—it is progress toward metabolic resilience.

Bottom Line

Stevia is a reasonable and evidence-supported alternative to sugar, especially when compared to artificial sweeteners that may negatively impact gut and metabolic health. As with all things in nutrition, moderation and individual context matter.

If you have questions about sweeteners, blood sugar, or gut health, we are here to help you personalize your approach.

Schedule Your Free Health Consultation

This information should not be substituted for medical or chiropractic advice. Any and all healthcare concerns, decisions, and actions must be made through the advice and counsel of a healthcare professional who is familiar with your updated medical history.